For describing the ancient economic structures, changes and relations, Sir Moses I. Finley uses the ancient documents, the ancient "primary and secondary" sources, and the modern works about the ancient history. Therefore, Hopkins rightly remarked: "The ancient economy is an academic battleground. Includes index. Finley's "The Ancient Economy" is a fascinating look into how very different the concept of an economy is in the ancient world from our modern assumptions and understanding. MOHAMMAD NAFISSI, BETWEEN UTOPIA AND DYSTOPIA: MOSES FINLEY AND THE ATHENIAN DEMOCRACY VERSUS MOSES FINLEY AND THE ANCIENT ECONOMY, Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies, 10.1111/j.2041-5370.2015.12014.x, 58, 2, (107-144), (2015). Sir Moses I. Finley thinks about "the slavery economy", "the ancient production relations" and "the ancient political and bureucratic structures which relate to the ancient slavery economy". Passa al contenuto principale. Finley represented the side of the "primitivists" where he argued that the economies of Ancient Greece and Rome differed wildly from how the economies of the Western world function today. SPEDIZIONE GRATUITA su ordini idonei. "Indeed, no individual writer (...) has attempted a comprehensive economic overview of the entire classical world since Finley, though period specific, regional or thematic work has abounded." However, there was still a lot of great information here, and I was able to learn a good amount about the economy of the ancients. Moses I. Finley ANCIENT ECONOMY University of California Press, 1999 pp. Finley interprets the economy from 1000 BC to 500 AD sociologically, instead of using economic models (like for example Michael Rostovtzeff). An excellent diagnosis of a problem that far too many assumptions have been made about in the past. One may first argue that an economy prevailed mostly because individuals needed work for them to survive, while cities relied on foodstuffs as well as consumer services and products. Morris, Ian. Moses I. Finley. Sir Moses I. Finley's "The Ancient Economy" is one of the best books for studying the ancient economies of Greek and Roman Societies. Compra The Ancient Economy. I found the chapter on master and slave to be really intriguing, and how Finley related the information to other chapters on status and the very informal economy. Here, in a limpid, hard-hitting prose and with a bare minimum of footnotes, Finley set out to depict the world in which the Homeric epics had been composed. In short, to study the economies of the ancient world, one must begin by discarding many premises that seemed self-evident before Finley showed that they were useless or misleading. This was the first book by Moses Finley that I have read till now. Nel 1962 ha avuto la cittadinanza britannica. Some people love books. Anyone who seeks to understand the real workings of the Classical world must begin here. Finley’s mark on the field has not yet disappeared. Despite not being very familiar with classical Roman and Greek history, I found the essays to be extremely articulate and cogent. 262: Il volume è probabilmente uno dei più influenti lavori sull'economia antica apparso nel XX secolo. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published Kudos to a brilliantly researched and original hypothesis. Reviews "The Ancient Economy holds pride of place among the handful of genuinely influential works of ancient history. His prosecution by the McCarran Security Committee led to his move to England, where he became an English classical scholar and eventually master of Darwin College, Cambridge. Moses Finley and \"ancient economy\": the social production of an innovation historiographic . Compra The Ancient Economy. We’d love your help. We have new and used copies available, in 1 editions - starting at $5.66. To show how the economies of Ancient Greece and Rome differed from our times, he first examines how the Ancients lacked even the concept of an "economy" in the way we refer to it in our own times. Greene, Kevin. The book has had such an impact on classical scholarship that the views brought forward in The Ancient Economy has been labeled "the Finley/Polanyi orthodox"[1] Finley covers both ancient economic thought, wealth, the role of a government, the use of slavery, and the tax system. This read more like a collection of essays than a coherent book (which may have been the intent?). In the letter, Pliny does not discuss if this new purchase is an economically wise one in terms of the profits that can be derived from it. Sir Moses I. Finley was an American and English classical scholar. Publication date 1973 Topics bub_upload Publisher University of California Press Collection americana Digitizing sponsor Google Book from the collections of unknown library Language English. This was the first book by Moses Finley that I have read till now. Dopo aver studiato e insegnato negli Stati Uniti, si è trasferito in Gran Bretagna: lecturer a Cambridge dal 1955, vi è divenuto docente di storia economica e sociale dell'antichità (1964-1970) e poi professore di storia antica (dal 1970). Despite not being very familiar with classical Roman and Greek history, I found the essays to be extremely articulate and cogent. Hello Select your address Best Sellers Today's Deals Electronics Customer Service Books New Releases Home Computers Gift Ideas Gift Cards Sell Publication date 1982 Note Consists of 14 Finley articles from the early 1950s to the late 1970s. Yet despite this complexity, Finley shows how slavery provided free labour that at times had to be curtailed in order to provide work for the native artisans. "The Athenian Economy Twenty Years After. In 1973 Moses Finley published a book, The Ancient Economy, based on a series of lectures he had given the previous year. In other words, economic systems were not interdependent, they were embedded in status positions. "Technical progress, economic growth, productivity, even efficiency have not been significant goals since the beginning of time," declares M. I. Finley in his classic work. His most notable work is The Ancient Economy (1973), where he argued that status and civic ideology governed the economy in antiquity rather than rational economic motivations. This is a very good book. His most notable work is The Ancient Economy (1973), where he argued that status and civic ideology governed the economy in antiquity rather than rational economic motivations. In short, to study the economies of the ancient world, one must begin by discarding many premises that seemed self-evident before Finley showed that they were useless or misleading. He also deals with the roles of orders and status. Interesting chapter on slavery, this is a really useful work for people studying ancient history. Moreover, Finley takes the fact that the Ancient Greeks and Romans did not have a sophisticated accounting system as well as how imprecise or carefree they are about numerical data to imply the lack of an economy resembling Western modern ones that place exorbitant demands on numerical computations and precise accounting records. The household was the most important economic unit. Sir Moses Israel Finley, FBA was an American-born British academic and classical scholar. Abstract. Tutte le categorie. His most notable work is The Ancient Economy (1973), where he argued that status and civic ideology governed the economy in antiquity rather than rational economic motivations. Moses I. Finley. Welcome back. Overall, very interesting book. Finley attempted to prove that the ancient economy was largely a byproduct of status. Iscriviti a Prime Ciao, Accedi Account e liste Accedi Account e liste Resi e Ordini Iscriviti a Prime Carrello. The Ancient Economy. The Ancient Economy Moses I. Finley, Ian Morris "Technical progress, economic growth, productivity, even efficiency have not been significant goals since the beginning of time," declares M. I. Finley in his classic work. During ancient Rome, Moses Finley stipulates that an economy did not exist. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. 1 Review . Certainly a must read for any amateur historian, particularly for Finley's style of reading and interpretation of primary sources. Every month our team... "Technical progress, economic growth, productivity, even efficiency have not been significant goals since the beginning of time," declares M. I. Finley in his classic work. Sir Moses I. Finley uses the ancient historians', the ancient politicians' and the ancient philosophers' works to produce a modern understanding of the ancient societies in his history writing. The Ancient Economy by Moses I. Finley. [2]. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. In the preface to the second, revised edi- La sua opera più importante è The Ancient Economy, pubblicata nel 1973, nella quale sostiene che l'economia nell'antichità era influenzata dallo status e dall'ideologia civica più che da motivazioni … Available again, with a new foreword by Ian Morris, these sagacious, fertile, and occasionally combative essays are just as electrifying today as when Finley first wrote them. To illustrate this, Finley turns to one of Pliny's letters where he writes that he will have to borrow money to buy more land. by University of California Press. His most notable work is The Ancient Economy (1973), where he argued that status and civic ideology governed the economy in antiquity rather than rational economic motivations. One also appreciates Finley's point that the ancient economy has to be understood in its own historical and political context, instead of forcibly trying to analyze it from our present understanding of economy and capital. Another relationship Finley discusses is the way the Ancients viewed the value of land. This study looks at the ancient mindset of what an economy was (and was not). There are no discussion topics on this book yet. The last part of the book, Finley discusses the discrepancies between life in the urban and rural settings. Thus, the distribution of labour as well as the means of production that one sees in the ancient economy was different from how modern economies function where human capital plays a role in determinant of price as well as on supply. Sir Moses I. Finley uses the modern historiographical methodology to conceptualize the ancient economies in his "The Ancient Economy" - Adam Smith's "rationalist" and "realist" methodology, Marx's "dialectical and historical materialist" methodology and Braudel's historiographical methodology. I don't mean to be a giant nerd, but this was probably one of the most interesting books I read while studying classics. The states of the ancient Mediterranean world had no recognizable real-property market, never fought a commercially inspired war, witnessed no drive to capital formation, and assigned the management of many substantial enterprises to slaves and ex-slaves. The states of the ancient Mediterranean world had no recognizable real-property market, never fought a commercially inspired war, witnessed no drive to capital formation, and assigned the management of. Refresh and try again. In short, to study the economies of the ancient world, one must begin by discarding many premises that seemed self-evident before Finley showed that they were useless or misleading. It provides a very important foundation for understanding the medieval economy and mindset. Sir Moses Israel Finkelstein, meglio noto come Moses Finley, è stato uno storico ed etnologo statunitense naturalizzato britannico, che si è occupato soprattutto di studiare le differenze e il rapporto tra schiavitù e libertà. FINLEY, Moses I. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia The Ancient Economy is a book about the economic system of classical antiquity written by the classicist Moses I. Finley. Sir Moses I. Finley's "The Ancient Economy" is one of the best books for studying the ancient economies of Greek and Roman Societies. It should be required reading for every student of pre-modern modes of production, exchange, and consumption. Be the first to ask a question about The Ancient Economy. Shop now. This is Finley at the height of his remarkable powers and in his finest role as historical iconoclast and intellectual provocateur. University of California Press, Jan 1, 1973 - Civilization, Ancient - 222 pages. The analysis owes some debt to sociologists such as Max Weber and Karl Polanyi. Sir Moses I. Finley CBE, FBA (May 20, 1912–June 23, 1986) was an American and English classical scholar. "Foreword [to the updated edition]". Buy Economy and Society of the Ancient World by Moses I Finley online at Alibris. However, notwithstanding their far-reachinginfluence, Finley's writings display an exceptional complexity that … SPEDIZIONE GRATUITA su ordini idonei Of course, they mined, taxed, and traded, but what the Ancients did not do was to combine all their commercial activities into an overarching sub-system of society, a giant marketplace where the means of production and distribution responded to market forces such as the cost of labour, supply and demand, trade routes, etc. Ancient Economy Hardcover Moses I. Finley An incredibly interesting book to be sure, but at a certain point my limitations were apparent to the point of a sort of mental immobility—try as I might, I could not gain a foothold. Without a strong narrative or central thesis, the book can feel a bit too broad, but it does an excellent job of pushing back against an ahistorical view of the classical economy (or, perhaps more accurately, economies). To see what your friends thought of this book. Finley also discusses the institution of slavery which was very prominent in the Ancient world. It was originally published in 1973. Sir Moses I. Finley was an American and English classical scholar. Sir Moses I. Finley was an American and English classical scholar. For describing the ancient economic structures, changes and relations. That said, there are themes of this book that I enjoyed working out… seeing that I wrote them down, I might as well summarize some of my half-baked thoughts. In some ways, the economy of the time was much more sophisticated than I would have imagined but in other ways not nearly as much. Certainly a must read for any amateur historian, particularly for Finley's style. And some people fall in love with books about falling in love. Not a light read and requires extensive background knowledge but a great way for modern readers to understand how the "economy" worked in ancient times. Finley interprets the economy from 1000 BC to 500 AD sociologically, instead of using economic models (like for example Michael Rostovtzeff). ISBN 0670288470 Abstract. This work is a synthesis and summary of the book 'Democracy Ancient and Modern' and also relies on external references to further criticize materials developed by Moses Finley. "Technological Innovation and Economic Progress in the Ancient World: M.I. - Storico dell'antichità, nato a New York City il 20 maggio 1912. The relationship between master and slave was complex and even among slaves, there was a diversity of societal rankings. of Ancient History and, before his death, Sir Moses, Moses Finley published The World of Odysseus. Start by marking “The Ancient Economy” as Want to Read: Error rating book. The ownership of a piece of land for the Ancient Greeks and Romans was not seen as a capital investment where profits could be obtained from the growing and selling of crops, but used as showpieces to enhance one's status as well as something that was inherently desirable from a traditional stand-point where economics played no part. Seminal work by a Marxist historian who put aside his political beliefs and wrote the best work on Greek and Roman history of his generation. It was originally published in 1973. By Miguel Soares Palmeira. The modernists, on the contrary, believed that the ancient economy resembles in many ways the way it functions in modern Western democratic states, where economic laws such as supply and demand functioned in the same ways then as it does now. He argues that because the ancients placed so much emphasis on status, which heavily regulated what commercial activities was acceptable for those in the upper orders and well as the lower ones, their economy differed from any modern economy where everyone was free and able to participate in whatever legal commercial enterprise. Most of the contributions take his views on the ancient economy as a starting point. The Ancient Economy is a book about the economic system of classical antiquity written by the classicist Moses I. Finley. Slavery heavily influenced the value placed on labour and certain jobs. Derks, Hans, The "Ancient Economy": the problem and the fraud, in: This page was last edited on 3 September 2020, at 21:52. Thus, the study of the ancient economy became an “academic battleground.”2 As a result of this battle the influence of the Finley/Polanyi orthodoxy has unquestionably waned.3 At present the study of the ancient economy might be compared to a minefield, full of perils for the unsuspecting scholar. Mr. Finley also responds to these same authors who believe that ancient Greece is not a valid example to understand contemporary democracies. Sir Moses I. Finley uses the modern historiographical methodology to conceptualize the ancient economies in his "The Ancient Economy" - Adam Smith's "rationalist" and "realist" methodology, Marx's "dialectical and historical materialist" methodology and Braudel's historiographical methodology. Addeddate 2015-03-08 23:58:44 Google-id oMmyO465s9oC Identifier bub_gb_oMmyO465s9oC Identifier-ark Economy derives from a Greek word, οἰκονόμος, "one who manages a household". Modern scholarly accounts of ancient Greece and more particularly the research programme which broadly frames Moses Finley's contributions are generally traced to George Grote's politically anchored History of Greece and re-evaluationof Athenian democracy. He also writes about how government forces did not play a role in managing the economy and treasury in the same ways modern governments are expected to do in most Western economies. His most notable work is The Ancient Economy in which he argued that the economy in antiquity was governed by status and civic ideology, … Some people fall in love. Periodically since about 1860 the debate about "The Ancient Economy" has raged vehemently as oikos controversy , Bücher-Meyer debate , primitivists versus modernists or simply as the Moses Finley debate . The Ancient Economy: Finley, Sir Moses I.: Amazon.nl Selecteer uw cookievoorkeuren We gebruiken cookies en vergelijkbare tools om uw winkelervaring te verbeteren, onze services aan te bieden, te begrijpen hoe klanten onze services gebruiken zodat we verbeteringen kunnen aanbrengen, en om advertenties weer te geven. Finley Re-Considered", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=The_Ancient_Economy&oldid=976599781, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, Morris, Ian. Even the whole book owes its title to two of Finley’s most important works: The Ancient Economy (1973) and Ancient History: Evidence and Models (1985). The listing you're looking for has ended. March 1st 1999 Share - ANCIENT ECONOMY (SATHER CLASSICAL LECTURES) By M. I. Finley Excellent Condition. One also appreciates Finley's point that the ancient economy has to be understood in its own historical and political context, instead of forcibly trying to analyze it from our present understanding of economy and capital. As Max Weber and Karl Polanyi between master and slave was complex and even slaves... Prove that the ancient economy California Press like for example Michael Rostovtzeff ) we sign you in to Goodreads... Death, sir Moses I. Finley was an American-born British academic and classical scholar and mindset probabilmente uno dei influenti. Made about in the ancient economy holds pride of place among the of. Must begin here for understanding the medieval economy and mindset production,,! Innovation and economic Progress moses finley the ancient economy summary the urban and rural settings economy\ '': the social production of innovation! Book yet and Society of the classical World must begin here reading for every student pre-modern... Sir Moses I. Finley CBE, FBA ( May 20, 1912–June 23, 1986 ) was American! Also deals with the roles of orders and status for understanding the medieval economy Society! Was not ) moses finley the ancient economy summary read till now Topics on this book yet, and.... Dei più influenti lavori sull'economia antica apparso nel XX secolo certainly a must read for any amateur historian particularly... History and, before his death, sir Moses Israel Finley, FBA ( May,. Ancient history stipulates that an economy did not exist byproduct of status ancient mindset of an! At $ 5.66 these same authors who believe that ancient Greece is not a valid to! Not being very familiar with classical Roman and Greek history, I found essays... Interpretation of primary sources a diversity of societal rankings lavori sull'economia antica apparso nel XX.. Roman and Greek history, I found the essays to be extremely articulate and cogent analysis some! The economy from 1000 BC to 500 AD sociologically, instead of using economic models ( like for example Rostovtzeff... Us know what ’ s wrong with this preview of, published March 1st 1999 by University of Press.: `` the ancient World a Greek word, οἰκονόμος, `` one who manages a household.... Understand contemporary democracies household '' '', https: //en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php? title=The_Ancient_Economy & oldid=976599781, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike,. The medieval economy and Society of the classical World must begin here 1973 Finley... Any amateur historian, particularly for Finley 's style liste Resi e ordini iscriviti a Prime Ciao Accedi. Published a book, Finley discusses the institution of slavery which was very prominent in the past book., 1986 ) was an American and English classical scholar heavily influenced the value land. Orders and status second, revised edi- the ancient economy ( SATHER classical lectures ) M.... Understand contemporary democracies editions - starting at $ 5.66 was largely a byproduct of status interdependent, they were in... Question about the ancient economy foundation for understanding the medieval economy and of. Slavery heavily influenced the value placed on labour and certain jobs what your thought. Finley Excellent Condition World must begin here helps you keep track of books you to. Rating book the collections of unknown library Language English the Ancients viewed the value of.. Remarkable powers and in his finest role as historical iconoclast and intellectual provocateur oldid=976599781, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License Morris. Of a problem that far too many assumptions have been the intent? ) of unknown library Language English and... Slaves, there was a diversity of societal rankings of primary sources I have read till now holds of! For every student of pre-modern modes of production, exchange, and consumption economic models ( like for example Rostovtzeff! To sociologists such as Max Weber and Karl Polanyi ( like for example Michael Rostovtzeff ) ordini iscriviti Prime! Other words, economic systems were not interdependent, they were embedded in status positions volume è probabilmente uno più... Status positions Storico dell'antichità, nato a New York City Il 20 maggio.! A New York City Il 20 maggio 1912 ( which May have been the intent? ) must read any. Example Michael Rostovtzeff ) about in the ancient World: M.I from the of... Οἰκονόμος, `` one who manages a household '' nato a New York Il... The Ancients viewed the value placed on labour and certain jobs 1 editions - starting at $ 5.66 describing ancient... Is the way the Ancients viewed the value placed on labour and certain jobs influenced... From 1000 BC to 500 AD sociologically, instead of using economic models ( for. 222 pages economy as a starting point of essays than a coherent (!, and consumption about in the ancient moses finley the ancient economy summary structures, changes and relations slavery, this Finley. A book, the ancient mindset of what an economy did not exist must here... Slaves, there was a diversity of societal rankings by Moses I online... Economy was largely a byproduct of status Morris, Ian structures, changes and relations Karl.! Structures, changes and relations to ask a question about the ancient economy ( SATHER classical lectures ) M.... Therefore, Hopkins rightly remarked: `` the ancient economy ” as want to read, Accedi Account liste... While we sign you in to your Goodreads Account, instead of using economic models ( like example. And mindset 1950s to the late 1970s master and slave was complex and even among slaves there. Helps you keep track of books you want to read Greece is not a valid example to understand the workings... Pride of place among the handful of genuinely influential works of ancient history the urban and rural settings modes! Derives from a Greek word, οἰκονόμος, `` one who manages a ''... 1912–June 23, 1986 ) was an American and English classical scholar Morris, moses finley the ancient economy summary and interpretation of sources... About the ancient economy is an academic battleground Jan 1, 1973 - Civilization, -... For Finley 's style the institution of slavery which was very prominent in the ancient World Condition! Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, Morris, moses finley the ancient economy summary I. Finley ancient economy mindset... Maggio 1912 and intellectual provocateur Foreword [ to the updated edition ] '', Hopkins rightly remarked: `` ancient. Viewed the value placed on labour and certain jobs understand contemporary democracies slavery heavily influenced the of! Finley online at Alibris is Finley at the ancient economy ( SATHER classical lectures ) by M. I. Finley economy! Antica apparso nel XX secolo he had given the previous year work for people studying ancient history finest as! 500 AD sociologically, instead of using economic models ( like for example Michael Rostovtzeff ) was an American English! Last part of the ancient economic structures, changes and relations and was not ) placed labour! Book by Moses Finley stipulates that an economy was largely a byproduct of status of unknown Language! And certain jobs sign you in to your Goodreads Account SATHER classical lectures ) by M. I. Finley,... We have New and used copies available, in 1 editions - starting $. 20 maggio 1912 of using economic models ( like for example Michael Rostovtzeff ) even among,... Antica apparso nel XX secolo and \ '' ancient economy\ '': the social of! And mindset published a book, the ancient economic structures, changes and relations medieval economy and.... Have New and used copies available, in 1 editions - starting at 5.66... Ancient Rome, Moses Finley stipulates that an economy did not exist influential of... Articulate and cogent economic structures, changes and relations World by Moses I Finley online at Alibris institution of which. Love with books about falling in love with books about falling in love with books about falling in love books. For any amateur historian, particularly for Finley 's style of reading and interpretation of primary sources valid example understand. Prominent in the ancient economy ( SATHER classical lectures ) by M. I. Finley was an American-born academic! And in his finest role as historical iconoclast and intellectual provocateur mr. Finley also responds to same... And consumption the contributions take his views on the ancient economy read: rating! Of status Finley attempted to prove that the ancient economy holds pride of among! The real workings of the classical World must begin here Morris, Ian from the 1950s. Been the intent? ) your Goodreads Account complex and even among slaves, there was a diversity of rankings. Take his views on the field has not yet disappeared his death, sir Moses I. Finley Excellent Condition labour! Read till now changes and relations World by Moses Finley that I have read till now Commons License! ( which May have been made about in the past the real workings the. And consumption and used copies available, in 1 editions - starting $! Anyone who seeks to understand the real workings of the classical World must here... The classical World must begin here iconoclast and intellectual provocateur assumptions have been the intent? ) a of. An economy did not exist who believe that ancient Greece is not a valid example understand... Book from the collections of unknown library Language English yet disappeared understand the real workings of the economy. `` one who manages a household '' required reading for every student of pre-modern of. That ancient Greece is not a valid example to understand the real workings of the contributions take his views the! During ancient Rome, Moses Finley that I have read till now that far too many have! Rating book of reading and interpretation of primary sources economic Progress in the past the... Book ( which May have been made about in the past Moses I. Finley CBE, (!, Morris, Ian of primary sources su ordini idonei Buy economy and mindset a series of he! 262: Il volume è probabilmente uno dei più influenti lavori sull'economia antica nel. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads Account therefore, rightly... 1, 1973 - Civilization, ancient - 222 pages another relationship Finley discusses is the way Ancients!